Traditional research firms talk a big game about cultural relevancy.
They’ll tell you to study the subcultures that matter to your brand. They might even suggest changing how you recruit.
But then? They fall back on the same tired vendors and panels full of professional respondents. Why? Because it’s easy. Because it’s fast. Because protecting their margin matters more than finding the right people.
It's true that cultural relevancy starts with cultural fluency. But the real question is: How do you actually find the people who shape culture?
How do you spot the sub-cultures worth studying? And how do you quickly and efficiently find the right people inside them?
Here's how I do it. I've built my own tool to quickly and efficiently scan platforms like Reddit, to surface people who are passionate and obsessed, in real time.
Here are the obsession signals I look for when recruiting online:
Engagement Intensity:
-
High comment-to-post ratios (people who engage more than they create)
-
Rapid response times to new posts in their interest areas
-
Consistent activity during unusual hours (suggesting they prioritize this over sleep/work)
-
Multi-platform activity around the same interest
Content Depth:
-
Extremely long posts or comments with technical detail
-
Fluent use of insider jargon
-
References to obscure stats, facts, or deep history
-
Publishing detailed guides, tutorials, or resources
Community Behaviour Patterns:
-
Moderating or heavily participating in niche communities
-
Cross-posting into related subreddits or forums
-
Consistently being among the first commenters on new posts
-
Strong opinions on etiquette, norms, or “real” fans
Collector/Documenter Energy:
-
Sharing spreadsheets, lists, or collections
-
Posting progress updates or stats over time
-
Creating comparison charts or analysis posts
-
Documenting personal progress/statistics over time
Social Signals:
-
Flair, bios, and usernames themed around the interest
-
Profile pictures related to their obsession
-
Mention of the interest in unrelated conversations
-
Quick to defend the culture—with receipts
Temporal Patterns:
-
Posting consistently over months or years
-
Activity spikes during key cultural moments
-
Maintaining engagement even during "off-seasons" for the interest
Some of these signals are easy to automate. Others require NLP and machine learning. And a few? They demand human intuition—foreknowledge of the subculture and its rhythms.
But this is the work.
This is how you find the people who will help your brand truly understand how to build cultural relevance.